Christian or Follower of the Way?
Examining the Historical Origins of the Church's Most Common Name
"Truth has nothing to fear from honest investigation."
Introduction
Few words carry as much religious, cultural, and historical significance as the word Christian. Today, billions of people around the world identify with this title, and countless churches, denominations, ministries, and traditions have been built around it. Yet a fascinating historical question remains:
Did the earliest followers of Jesus identify themselves as Christians?
The evidence from Scripture and early historical sources suggests a more nuanced answer than many modern believers realize. While the term Christian eventually became the accepted designation for followers of Jesus, the earliest believers were more commonly known by other names, including disciples, believers, saints, brethren, and members of what the Book of Acts repeatedly calls The Way.
This distinction is not merely academic. It invites us to consider how the first followers of Jesus understood their identity and whether modern Christianity fully reflects the faith and practice of the movement that emerged in the first century.
The First Appearance of the Term "Christian"
The term Christian appears only three times in the New Testament:
Acts 11:26
Acts 26:28
1 Peter 4:16
The first occurrence is found in Acts 11:26:
"And the disciples were called Christians first in Antioch."
The wording is significant. Luke does not write that the disciples called themselves Christians. Rather, he states that they "were called" Christians.
Many scholars interpret this passive construction as evidence that the title originated outside the believing community rather than as a self-designation. F. F. Bruce notes that Antioch was known for coining labels and nicknames for various social and political groups. Craig Keener similarly observes that the term likely functioned as a designation created by outsiders attempting to identify those associated with Christ.
The Greek word Christianoi combines Christos (Christ, Messiah) with the Latin suffix -ianus, commonly used in the Roman world to identify followers or supporters of a leader.
For this reason, many scholars conclude that the term likely originated as an outsider label. Some further suggest it may have carried a dismissive, mocking, or derogatory tone, though historians differ on the degree to which this can be proven with certainty. Paul Trebilco argues that the designation was almost certainly not the preferred self-description of the earliest believers.
What is clear is that the title did not originate as the primary name believers used for themselves.
The Earliest Identity: Followers of the Way
Long before the term Christian appears, believers are repeatedly associated with what Luke calls The Way.
Consider the following passages:
Acts 9:2
Acts 19:9
Acts 19:23
Acts 22:4
Acts 24:14
Acts 24:22
The frequency of this expression suggests it was one of the earliest designations for the Jesus movement.
Acts 24:14 records Paul's own words:
"I worship the God of our fathers, believing everything laid down by the Law and written in the Prophets, according to the Way which they call a sect."
This title likely derives from Jesus' declaration:
"I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me." (John 14:6)
For the earliest disciples, faith was not merely a set of beliefs. It was a way of life—a path to be followed.
The phrase Follower of the Way emphasized discipleship, obedience, and daily imitation of Jesus rather than membership in a distinct religious institution.
Larry Hurtado notes that the earliest Jesus movement developed within Judaism and initially understood itself as a community centered on the Messiah rather than as a separate religion called Christianity. The first believers saw themselves primarily as disciples of Jesus and participants in God's covenant promises.
Other Names Used by the Earliest Believers
The New Testament uses several terms far more frequently than Christian:
Disciples
The most common designation in the Gospels and Acts.
Believers
Those who had placed their faith in Jesus as Messiah.
Saints
Meaning "holy ones" or those set apart for God's purposes.
Brethren (Brothers and Sisters)
Emphasizing spiritual family and unity.
Servants of God
Highlighting devotion and obedience.
Followers of the Way
Emphasizing a lifestyle of discipleship.
The rarity of the word Christian compared to these other descriptions is noteworthy. The early church appears to have understood itself less as an institution and more as a community walking in the teachings of Jesus.
From Movement to Religious Identity
Although the title Christian may have originated as an outsider designation, it eventually became embraced by believers themselves.
By the time Peter wrote his first epistle, the term appears to have become a recognized identity among followers of Jesus:
"Yet if anyone suffers as a Christian, let him not be ashamed, but let him glorify God in that name." (1 Peter 4:16)
This passage demonstrates an important historical transition.
A title that may have begun as an external label became a badge of honor. Early believers were willing to endure persecution under that name because their allegiance to Christ mattered more than public opinion.
History offers many examples of groups reclaiming names originally imposed upon them. Christianity appears to have undergone a similar process.
Yet as centuries passed, the meaning of the word expanded.
As Christianity spread through the Roman Empire and eventually across the world, the term came to encompass a vast range of traditions, institutions, cultures, and theological perspectives.
Today the word Christian may describe:
A devoted disciple of Jesus
A church member
A denominational identity
A cultural affiliation
A political identity
A family tradition
This reality creates an important question:
Does carrying the label necessarily mean one is following the path of Jesus?
The Problem of Labels
Labels can be useful.
They can also become substitutes for reality.
In the first century, followers of Jesus were known not merely by what they called themselves but by how they lived. The Book of Acts emphasizes transformed lives, sacrificial generosity, devotion to prayer, care for the poor, and radical commitment to Jesus.
Modern Christianity often reflects these same qualities.
Yet at other times, Christianity becomes associated with political agendas, institutional loyalties, denominational rivalries, and cultural traditions that would have been unfamiliar to the earliest disciples.
This observation is not an argument against the title Christian.
Rather, it is an invitation to ask whether our understanding of the word aligns with its historical roots.
The critical question is not merely what we call ourselves.
The critical question is whether we truly follow Jesus.
What About the Meaning "Little Christ"?
A popular teaching holds that the term Christian means "little Christ."
While this interpretation has devotional value and has been repeated throughout church history, most modern scholars caution that this is likely not the precise linguistic meaning of the word.
The suffix -ianus generally indicated association, allegiance, or belonging to a particular leader. Thus, Christianoi most naturally meant those associated with Christ or those belonging to Christ.
Yet even if "little Christ" is not the exact linguistic meaning, the concept itself reflects a biblical aspiration—to become increasingly conformed to the image of Christ.
Whether one prefers the expression "little Christ" or "one belonging to Christ," the challenge remains the same:
To live in faithful imitation of Jesus.
Common Objections and Responses
If Christian Was an Outsider Label, Why Does Peter Use It Positively?
Peter's acceptance of the title demonstrates that believers eventually embraced it. However, acceptance of a name does not necessarily reveal its origin.
Both statements can be true:
The term originated outside the believing community.
Believers later adopted it as a badge of honor.
First Peter demonstrates acceptance, not necessarily origin.
Doesn't Christian Simply Mean Belonging to Christ?
Yes, linguistically that is a strong possibility.
The issue is not whether Christians belong to Christ.
The issue is whether Christian was the earliest and primary designation used by the first believers.
The evidence suggests that disciples, saints, believers, brethren, and followers of The Way were more common self-identifiers.
Is It Wrong to Call Myself a Christian Today?
Absolutely not.
Nothing in this essay suggests believers should abandon the title Christian.
The New Testament itself uses the term positively.
The issue is not whether the title is acceptable.
The issue is whether the title alone is sufficient.
A label cannot replace discipleship.
Are Followers of the Way and Christians the Same Thing?
Historically speaking, yes.
The believers known as followers of The Way eventually became known throughout the Roman world as Christians.
The difference lies primarily in emphasis.
Christian emphasizes one's association with Christ.
Follower of the Way emphasizes walking in His teachings.
Both communicate important truths.
Conclusion
The historical evidence suggests that the earliest followers of Jesus most commonly identified themselves as disciples, believers, saints, brethren, and members of The Way. The title Christian appears to have emerged first in Antioch as a designation given by outsiders and may have carried a dismissive or mocking tone before eventually being embraced by believers themselves.
Yet the ultimate question is not merely what the term meant in the first century. The more important question is whether the modern use of the word still reflects the life, mission, and discipleship of those earliest followers of Jesus.
In an age marked by denominational divisions, cultural Christianity, political movements, celebrity ministries, and competing claims about faith, each person must examine the evidence for themselves.
History invites us to look beyond inherited traditions and popular assumptions to ask a simple question:
Were the first believers primarily identified by a religious label, or by their commitment to walk in the way of Jesus?
Whether one embraces the title Christian as a noble name of allegiance to Christ, or prefers the earlier biblical designation Follower of the Way, the challenge remains the same:
Pursue truth rather than tradition.
Examine evidence rather than assumptions.
Seek faithful discipleship rather than mere religious identity.
The historical record is available to all who are willing to investigate it honestly.
Labels matter less than loyalty.
Names matter less than obedience.
What ultimately distinguished the earliest believers was not what they called themselves, but whom they followed.
Perhaps that remains the most important lesson for believers today.
May every reader be willing to search the Scriptures, examine the historical evidence, test long-held assumptions, and decide for themselves—not based upon tradition, denominational preference, or popular opinion, but upon truth.
For in the end, the question is not whether we bear the name.
The question is whether we walk in the Way.
Scholarly Bibliography
Bruce, F. F. The Book of Acts. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1988.
Hurtado, Larry W. Destroyer of the Gods: Early Christian Distinctiveness in the Roman World. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2016.
Keener, Craig S. Acts: An Exegetical Commentary. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2012.
Trebilco, Paul. "What Shall We Call Each Other? Part One: The Issue of Self-Designation in the Pastoral Epistles." Tyndale Bulletin 65, no. 2 (2014): 225–255.
Wilken, Robert Louis. The Christians as the Romans Saw Them. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2003.
Wright, N. T. Paul: A Biography. New York: HarperOne, 2018.
Comments